Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

5 cylinder engines...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 5 cylinder engines...

    Right, all this talk about what bits fit on what has propted me to ask a question thats been bugging me for a long time!

    In recent years we have had 5 cylinder engines from a few major manufacturers. Audi for many many years, Volvo in the 850 and Fiat in the Coupe. Now, I suspect that there may be some similarities between the designs because Volvo don't (or at least they didn't used to) make their own engines from scratch but contracted other firms or formed alliances with other manufacturers: renault and peugeot on the old V6 ones, mitsi for diesels in the charisma/S40 shared platform and renault provided most of the 480Turbo unit. I have also heard that they contracted a certain UK engine specialist to develope a V10 but I think it was canned. I can't see that Fiat would have developed their own unit and justified it financially by only ever fitting it to one model (I think it was only used in the Coupe).

    So, are there any commonalities between these units? The volvo 5 cyl head is massive so if it bolts straight on it may (I stress MAY) be a better option to port properly (no individual coil packs thought). Volvo have also gone from 2.3 litres up to 2.5 litres in recent years so there may be some options on cranks.

    Any thoughts or facts that people could offer would be appreciated. I have to take my dad's engine out over Xmas for various maintenance jobs (Volvo 850R) but I don't really want to start taking both nis and my engine completely apart to compare parts. I have loads to do on my own car during my vacation so I won't really have the time!

    Are there other 5 cylider engines that might be similar?....couldn't think of any more 5 pots!

    Thanks in advance

    Lee
    1995 S2 Avant with some upgrades

    Designun Limited....
    Aerospace, Space and Motorsport Design Consultancy and hardware supply.

  • #2
    Maybe a way to see if the heads are similar like you have suggested the MAYbe is to compare head gaskets? Keep your old mans one and iam sure somone on the board can supply an S2 one?

    Your right with VOLVO not producing much of there own stuff, i belive all the units in the 400 series (440 460 + 480) were Renaults units which originally started their life designed as a DIESELS!

    I wouldn't be supprised if VOLVO had Produced their own 5 pot engine for the 850 (with help from Audi of course) because the 850 was a revoluntionary brakethrough for VOLVO in car manufacturing designed to carry or bring (which ever you prefere) VOLVO in to the next decade.

    The first VOLVO 5 pot was launced in Aug 91 ( i think?) on the release of the "K" plate and is still being produced today! Making it viable to design and manufacture their own units. The design of that enngine has now had 12 or so years to pay and i belive it will have done just that, especially with the super blown unit in the T5, T5R and R cars! These or this should i say, was the engine which made VOLVO in the 90's!

    (sorry guys, i hold a bit of a soft spot for the swedish tank as well as the audi's too!)
    Money is everything! Second to Power of course!!! But money breeds power??

    Comment


    • #3
      Glen, thank you for pointing out the obvious!!

      Why didn't I think of getting some head gaskets! I am employed to "think outside the box" as I do new product development so that should have been obvious to me! Doh! It has been a long week!

      I am not taking my dads head off but could always take and Audi gasket to a Volvo stealership and compare one at the parts counter. I have got to collect his new bits anway. Man! Volvo parts are dirt cheap these days! A new clutch kit for him was about 160 quid for cover plate and clutch...not bad for a 250 horse engine! Volvo prices used to be stupid but was told by the parts guy that they had to drop prices to compete with people like Euro Car Parts and German&Swedish. How refreshing! Wouldn't buy one though: flat torque profile from 2k to 5k is nice but the chassis is crap and rods and gearbox are weak and it redlines at only 6k!

      Cheers mate!
      1995 S2 Avant with some upgrades

      Designun Limited....
      Aerospace, Space and Motorsport Design Consultancy and hardware supply.

      Comment


      • #4
        Can't think of any more 5 pots myself but fiat do fit the 5 in the Marea as well as the coupe. If any of you guys know someone with one and they want a timing belt done.... REFUSE!!!! Book gives about 15 hours!! Engine out! Quite funny actually the book reads..... 1.jack up car 2. remove ancillaries 3.remove engine!!!! Or something just as stupid. They make it sound so easy!! lol.
        Wish you had mentioned the head gasket a few weeks ago, I just did the gasket on Beeties car!
        I am surprised Ford haven't used Volvo's engine as they own them!

        Lee, do you really need to take a gasket to Volvo? Can't you get a faxed copy from both dealers to compare? I know it's not the same as the physical object but you should be able to compare.

        Chris.
        A6 Avant Tdi 110 because as the fuel prices keep going up I am so happy to be getting 649.8 miles to a tank of diesel!! (£50)

        Comment


        • #5
          I'm pretty sure Fiat did develop it's own 5 cylinder itself. It was fitted both NA and turbocharged at least on Coupé and K (Lancia K). Than was also made a 2.4 TD IL5 for the K and Lybra.

          Marco
          Last edited by Pisobiker; 6 December 2003, 01:06.

          Comment


          • #6
            Volkswagens come with a 5 cylinder in the Golf IVS and jetta Ivs

            Don't forget Ford owns volvo too... I am sure the Fix Or Repair Daily parts are making there ways into the volvos.

            Cheers
            Josh
            I chose not to choose life: I chose something else. And the reasons? There are no reasons. Who need reasons when you've got quattro?

            Comment


            • #7
              The 5 pot engine in the Volvo 850 series WAS an Audi design, the 850 TDI was an Audi engine complete, lifted straight from the early A6 ( I did a cambelt and tensioner change on one last year, using VAG parts!!)

              Siena

              Comment


              • #8
                The VW 5 cylinder engine is a V5 isn't it? 2 cylinders on one bank and 3 on the other I think.

                I agree with you about Volvos. Quality isn't that good these days and certainly isn't that robust anmore. My dad had a piece of trim come off at 145 mph cos it was so flimsy. It's the plastic piece that runs along the roofline from the windscreen to trunk just peeled back. Thats naff!!

                Didn't know about the straight 5 engine used in different Fiat models though. Maybe it is their own work. The volvo head is really big so I wonder is it is better. The Audi 4V unit is a really a nice design though. Can't wait for Vagsports 5 valve head though. If the price is right! Siena, have you ever thought about using the valve angles, ports, and combustoin camber geometries from a 1.8T engine as a pattern for the 5 valve head? Repeat the geometry of each chamber and associted 5 times and realign the oil and waterways. You will be talking custom cams, manifolds etc but at least the important geometries and material thicknesses can all be copied. The design is done for you! I know Paul at VAGPARTS had some old knackered 1.8T heads. That could be your templates readily available!!
                1995 S2 Avant with some upgrades

                Designun Limited....
                Aerospace, Space and Motorsport Design Consultancy and hardware supply.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by Vagsport
                  The 5 pot engine in the Volvo 850 series WAS an Audi design, the 850 TDI was an Audi engine complete, lifted straight from the early A6 ( I did a cambelt and tensioner change on one last year, using VAG parts!!)

                  Siena
                  Do you know how far the commonality extends? Blocks, cranks? Which Volvo engines are the same as the Audi ones?
                  1995 S2 Avant with some upgrades

                  Designun Limited....
                  Aerospace, Space and Motorsport Design Consultancy and hardware supply.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    A 1.8T head IS being used initially, welding an extra cylinder to the 4 zyl head. As far as I know, it involves a lot of machining, but it will not be run. It will be used as a template to make a complete new casting, after the oil / waterways have been suitably alligned.

                    The Volvo engines are based on an Audi design, so are not compatible wit VAG units. The only similar engine is the 850 2.5 TDI, which has the same codes as the Audi unit. A point to remember, for those still running K Jet on 10V turbo and N/A engines, you can adapt the EFI loom and ECU from a Volvo 5 zyl 10V / 10V turbo, I dabbled with it when my type 85 Coupe q was standard, and it worked a treat. Didn't take any power figures at the time, but the car was certainly quicker. Trouble is it was also a lot smoother and lost most of the gruff 5 zyl "warble" which most of us find so addictive.

                    A plus point for those who want to go down the EFI route, the Volvo parts are very cheap used, I paid £75 for the loom, ECU and robbed the engine of all required sensors. The only part ot the conversion that cost besides the parts was the modifications done to the original inlet manifold, allowing the Volvo injectors to be fitted. This cost another £60, but was well worth the money spent.


                    Siena

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      As far as I know the Fiat group 5 cyl engine is their own design. As Marco said it's used in many models, Coupe, Kappa, Stilo Abarth, Bravo HGT and so on. 2.0 and 2.4 litre versions are (or were) available. These things have a neat plastic timing belt tensioner... my pal's Kappa got 20 new valves because of that

                      And yes, the Volvo engines are designed in cooperation with Audi. Petrol models were their "own" from the begining, but diesels were Audi units till a year or two ago when they finally did their own.

                      Merc had a 5 cyl diesel also (250D I think).
                      -

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Nice info. Thanks. Plastic tensioners don't sound too clever!
                        1995 S2 Avant with some upgrades

                        Designun Limited....
                        Aerospace, Space and Motorsport Design Consultancy and hardware supply.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          The Volvo 5 pot is virtually the same as our as my mates dad has one, and its a 2.5 tdi, the block and head are the same length etc, next time i see him i'll get my tape measure our and worry him
                          Graham
                          Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler.--:Albert Einstein

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Yeah, the 2.5 TDI's ARE the same as the Audi units, but the petrol units ARE not.

                            Siena

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              VW's engine is a bit of a weird one. Its a single head design, the cylinders are slightly offset. Its a 12 degree V. But the top of the block is flat :wacked: my old man has got a V5 Passat, its too new and he wont let me pull it apart to see what its really like.
                              sigpic
                              Tom C - www.rcmr.co.uk
                              Audi UR Quattro
                              Audi 100 C3 2.0 5 cyl 115ps
                              Audi S2 - 07k engine project aiming for 800ps
                              Audi B5 RS4 645ps 911nm

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X