Power

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Si Blythe
    S2Forum Addict
    • Jul 2005
    • 346
    • Country: United Kingdom

    #1

    Power

    Is it possible to get a reliable 320 bhp from a standard ABY with just a chip and turbo?
    You might leave the S2 fold every so often - but you'll always come back!
  • T2Andy
    S2Forum Extremist
    • Mar 2005
    • 1903
    • Country: United Kingdom

    #2
    Maybe add injectors ,exhaust, intercooler ,you can't add a bigger turbo without adding more fuel and then getting rid of the extra gasses !
    sigpic

    Comment

    • prj
      S2Forum Zealot
      • Mar 2010
      • 6308
      • Country: Estonia

      #3
      You will run out of injectors.
      You can fit 3B injectors though, and then it should be okay.
      http://tuner.ee - http://www.facebook.com/tuner.ee

      Comment

      • re2500
        S2Forum Fiend
        • May 2007
        • 2185
        • Country: Wales

        #4
        I would say minimum Injectors and Downpipe to go with the turbo and map.
        Black B3 1990 CQ 2.3E converted to ABY & 6spd. (301bhp) - Now Sold
        03 Dolphin B6 S4 Avant LPG - New Daily Wagon
        01 Silver D2 A8 3.7 quattro sport - SOLD

        "Difficult is worth doing"

        Comment

        • prj
          S2Forum Zealot
          • Mar 2010
          • 6308
          • Country: Estonia

          #5
          DP is not needed for 330 hp imo.
          I personally think this is not worth the cost. Just get 280 or 290hp (with 3 bar map sensor) remap or go RS2.
          http://tuner.ee - http://www.facebook.com/tuner.ee

          Comment

          • Dan
            S2Forum Extremist
            • Jun 2008
            • 1242
            • Country: United Kingdom

            #6
            Originally posted by prj
            You will run out of injectors.
            You can fit 3B injectors though, and then it should be okay.
            Were the 3B injectors bigger than ABY then? If so, what was the reason for the downsize?
            1993 ABY Coupe | BMW R1200 GS
            A6 3.0 TDI Quattro (aka Sonic's 'ring support/cargo vehicle )

            Comment

            • ericd
              S2Forum Extremist
              • Nov 2003
              • 1240
              • Country: Scotland

              #7
              Originally posted by Si Blythe
              Is it possible to get a reliable 320 bhp from a standard ABY with just a chip and turbo?
              yes it is possible, the devil is in the detail though, you'd need something similar to the
              "small hybrid 24/26 turbo) mtm, nothelle et al, well discussed and dissected elsewhere on the forum , as for the chip (software,firmware,flash,middleware) depending on your level of pedantry , the same applies the options and suppliers are well discussed , paul, mrc would be your way forward.

              Comment

              • loxxrider
                S2Forum Fanatic
                • Mar 2010
                • 95
                • Country: United States

                #8
                3b injectors do not flow enough for that much power unless you upped the fuel pressure a LOT. At that point I don't even know if they would open anymore.

                Comment

                • prj
                  S2Forum Zealot
                  • Mar 2010
                  • 6308
                  • Country: Estonia

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Dan
                  Were the 3B injectors bigger than ABY then? If so, what was the reason for the downsize?
                  Yes. They upped the fuel pressure to 4 bar and downsized the injectors. Fuel flow remained unchanged.
                  3B injectors are 323 cc at 3 bar, AAN injectors are 280cc at 3 bar.
                  On 3B the FPR is 3 bar, on AAN it is 4 bar.
                  280cc injectors at 4 bar are like 323cc at 3 bar.
                  323cc injectors at 4 bar are like 373cc at 3 bar.

                  Originally posted by loxxrider
                  3b injectors do not flow enough for that much power unless you upped the fuel pressure a LOT. At that point I don't even know if they would open anymore.
                  Check your facts before making such statements, because you are very wrong.
                  3B injectors at 4 bar will work fine upto ~340 hp.
                  And they have no issues opening/operating at that fuel pressure. Multiple cars running perfectly fine that way.
                  Also, 1 bar fuel pressure is not "a LOT".

                  So, cheapest way for that power on AAN/ABY is 3B injectors and k26 hybrid turbo + custom mapping.
                  You don't need anything else.
                  Then again, it is a lot of trouble for a 10% power increase.
                  http://tuner.ee - http://www.facebook.com/tuner.ee

                  Comment

                  • T2Andy
                    S2Forum Extremist
                    • Mar 2005
                    • 1903
                    • Country: United Kingdom

                    #10
                    I managed 335bhp with
                    Rs2 injectors
                    Supersprint exhaust
                    K26 hybrid
                    Head work
                    044 fuel pump
                    Rs2 air box
                    Rs2 intercooler
                    No air leaks !!
                    Mtm soft wear
                    This is very reliable but not cheap IMO but the performance is great compared to a chipped car only ,loads more toque ,i could add a hoffer spec hybrid to this spec and
                    Take it to 400hp for another £600
                    sigpic

                    Comment

                    • prj
                      S2Forum Zealot
                      • Mar 2010
                      • 6308
                      • Country: Estonia

                      #11
                      Originally posted by T2Andy
                      I managed 335bhp with
                      Rs2 injectors
                      Supersprint exhaust
                      K26 hybrid
                      Head work
                      044 fuel pump
                      Rs2 air box
                      Rs2 intercooler
                      No air leaks !!
                      Mtm soft wear
                      This is very reliable but not cheap IMO but the performance is great compared to a chipped car only ,loads more toque ,i could add a hoffer spec hybrid to this spec and
                      Take it to 400hp for another £600
                      Injectors are overkill, exhaust is not needed, fuel pump not needed, headwork is not needed, airbox is not needed, intercooler is not needed.
                      Also, your software was not even for your setup. And because someone tells you it is "MTM" or it is written "MTM" in vag-com, does not mean it is MTM software.

                      I would say considering your hardware spec, the end result is a bit disappointing. You would be much better off running a RS2 or k26/k27 hybrid turbo and proper mapping, because the rest of your car is pretty much RS2 spec.
                      http://tuner.ee - http://www.facebook.com/tuner.ee

                      Comment

                      • T2Andy
                        S2Forum Extremist
                        • Mar 2005
                        • 1903
                        • Country: United Kingdom

                        #12
                        90% of the spec came as a mtm package ,the car ran very lean with standard inj on that spec and I got the pump cheap ,after adding the exhaust it was like night and day so that was well worth the effort and cost ,it is a mtm ecu and soft wear and I know you will say it wants a custom map which it does but the afr are good just a little rich at the top after 5500k rpm which I can live with at the mo but as I might have 9 points by next week it's all pointless at the min lol
                        sigpic

                        Comment

                        • loxxrider
                          S2Forum Fanatic
                          • Mar 2010
                          • 95
                          • Country: United States

                          #13
                          Originally posted by prj
                          Yes. They upped the fuel pressure to 4 bar and downsized the injectors. Fuel flow remained unchanged.
                          3B injectors are 323 cc at 3 bar, AAN injectors are 280cc at 3 bar.
                          On 3B the FPR is 3 bar, on AAN it is 4 bar.
                          280cc injectors at 4 bar are like 323cc at 3 bar.
                          323cc injectors at 4 bar are like 373cc at 3 bar.


                          Check your facts before making such statements, because you are very wrong.
                          3B injectors at 4 bar will work fine upto ~340 hp.
                          And they have no issues opening/operating at that fuel pressure. Multiple cars running perfectly fine that way.
                          Also, 1 bar fuel pressure is not "a LOT".

                          So, cheapest way for that power on AAN/ABY is 3B injectors and k26 hybrid turbo + custom mapping.
                          You don't need anything else.
                          Then again, it is a lot of trouble for a 10% power increase.
                          No need to be so defensive. I know my facts just fine. I was running out of fuel on stock injectors on a 3b at 3 bar on a k24. I also ran out of fuel at only 6psi and 6500 RPMs on a Holset turbo. I know the limits of these injectors at 3 bar, so don't tell me to get my facts straight. I have the logs to back it up too.

                          Also, who said I was referring to 4 bar when I said "a lot"? Of course they will open at 4 bar. I meant more like 5 bar plus. They probably wouldn't perform well under those conditions (if at all) and probably would still struggle to make the power.

                          3B are OE part number 034.906.031, Bosch number 0-280-155-931.
                          Flow rate is 28.5lb/hr, 300cc/min, at 3bar... at 4 bar they would be 348cc/min and at 5 bar, 389cc

                          You need more injector for that power at 4 bar. At 5 bar they might make that power if you are 90% duty cycle or higher. Thats all theory there...but it backs up my experiences with my personal car and my personal tune and logs and everything.

                          Now who's got their facts straight? Where did your numbers come from?

                          Comment

                          • prj
                            S2Forum Zealot
                            • Mar 2010
                            • 6308
                            • Country: Estonia

                            #14
                            Originally posted by loxxrider
                            Also, who said I was referring to 4 bar when I said "a lot"? Of course they will open at 4 bar. I meant more like 5 bar plus. They probably wouldn't perform well under those conditions (if at all) and probably would still struggle to make the power.
                            They work perfectly fine at 4 bar.
                            Of course you will run out at 3 bar...
                            At 5 bar they start having severe latency issues.
                            3B are OE part number 034.906.031, Bosch number 0-280-155-931.
                            Flow rate is 28.5lb/hr, 300cc/min, at 3bar... at 4 bar they would be 348cc/min and at 5 bar, 389cc
                            Okay, got the number wrong.
                            You need more injector for that power at 4 bar. At 5 bar they might make that power if you are 90% duty cycle or higher. Thats all theory there...but it backs up my experiences with my personal car and my personal tune and logs and everything.
                            Incorrect. It works fine at 4 bar and no you don't run at 90% duty even then. Not at 320bhp anyway.
                            Now who's got their facts straight? Where did your numbers come from?
                            Off the top of my head, sorry if I got one number wrong.
                            Injector duty cycle comes from experience tuning various cars + logging opening duration from VAG-COM.
                            Hell, at 5 bar they are enough for a K26/K27 at 1.8 bar. But as I said, severe latency issues, so it is not feasible (yes, this is also from experience).

                            This is all because you don't run this much boost to redline. Especially not with the older turbos. You have a high midrange and then taper to redline. At 6000 rpm you won't be having more than 1.2-1.3 bar of boost with a small k26 hybrid and 3B injectors at 4 bar will be just enough for that.

                            Originally posted by T2Andy
                            I know you will say it wants a custom map which it does but the afr are good just a little rich at the top after 5500k rpm which I can live with at the mo
                            Saying that "AFR are fine" so "my tune is fine" is very wrong. AFR is just a tool to control combustion chamber temperature. Fitting odd chips means you are not running as much boost as you could and not enough timing, which means you are lots down on power.
                            Last edited by prj; 3 December 2010, 16:32.
                            http://tuner.ee - http://www.facebook.com/tuner.ee

                            Comment

                            • loxxrider
                              S2Forum Fanatic
                              • Mar 2010
                              • 95
                              • Country: United States

                              #15
                              OK so if we agree on these points, don't call my information incorrect. Its purely a mis-communication issue.

                              One needs to decrease boost severely at higher RPMs on these cars with injectors that small. That is something that wasn't really discussed. I can see how that power can be made at lower RPMs, but it can't be carried into the higher RPMs. Thats all I'm saying. So what if you make 340hp if you only peak there for a short time? My claim was more of the fact that they wont make that power up higher in the RPMs. So we can agree there.

                              I too experienced this on my car. Had to keep it down to about 15psi around 8k.

                              Comment

                              Working...