K26/GT2871 R good for RS2

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • kalsket
    S2Forum Fanatic
    • Sep 2004
    • 78
    • Country: Finland

    #16
    Why anyone should? It has same compressor as 2871 with larger hot side. There is no backpressure problem with 2871 so why take bigger turbine?
    4F 2006 avant 3.0tdi quattro
    4B 2002 S6 avant quattro
    typ85 sedan quattro with "minor" changes

    Comment

    • DamoM
      S2Forum Addict
      • Feb 2005
      • 352
      • Country: United Kingdom

      #17
      Originally posted by kalsket
      Why anyone should? It has same compressor as 2871 with larger hot side. There is no backpressure problem with 2871 so why take bigger turbine?
      well I guess the fact that is has a bigger turbine means that it has better characteristics at higher revs, hence why they say that it is good for 500 bhp applications? I have ione on my 10v UR quattro and you get full boost by 3000 rpm and superb flow at higher revs.

      Depends what you are after I suppose; quicker spool up than an RS2 turbo and (in reality as I believe certain claims are a little optimistic) potential for up to 400 bhp or same spool as an RS2 turbo with potential for 50 bhp more?....different strokes for different folks......
      *1986 ur quattro,2.5 stroker
      *1995 Nogaro Blue RS2,Md357
      *1991 RR 20v quattro
      *2000 Nogaro Blue RS4,RS6 turbos,tubulars,custom 3" downpipes,Miltek,FMIC,big injectors,RS6 big brakes,RNS-E satnav/TV,592bhp/600lbs

      Comment

      • Erikb
        S2Forum Maniac
        • Jul 2004
        • 648
        • Country: Netherlands

        #18
        But the reason I would go for the 2871 is that it already produces over 450 hp. Look at the thread pekka 400+. He has this turbo and it produces 458 hp.
        Getting everything sorted out for my 5++ hp project

        Comment

        • DamoM
          S2Forum Addict
          • Feb 2005
          • 352
          • Country: United Kingdom

          #19
          Originally posted by Erikb
          But the reason I would go for the 2871 is that it already produces over 450 hp. Look at the thread pekka 400+. He has this turbo and it produces 458 hp.
          I am eating my words.....!
          *1986 ur quattro,2.5 stroker
          *1995 Nogaro Blue RS2,Md357
          *1991 RR 20v quattro
          *2000 Nogaro Blue RS4,RS6 turbos,tubulars,custom 3" downpipes,Miltek,FMIC,big injectors,RS6 big brakes,RNS-E satnav/TV,592bhp/600lbs

          Comment

          • kalsket
            S2Forum Fanatic
            • Sep 2004
            • 78
            • Country: Finland

            #20
            Erikb, I have that turbo and 450+ mentioned in that topic, Pekkas ex-car has GT2540R and about 430Hp.
            4F 2006 avant 3.0tdi quattro
            4B 2002 S6 avant quattro
            typ85 sedan quattro with "minor" changes

            Comment

            • Erikb
              S2Forum Maniac
              • Jul 2004
              • 648
              • Country: Netherlands

              #21
              Kalsket, can you tell me what the difference is between the GT2540R and the GT2871R. Which one would you recommend?
              Getting everything sorted out for my 5++ hp project

              Comment

              • maRS2
                S2Forum Addict
                • Oct 2003
                • 366
                • Home: France Current: Thailand

                #22
                What would be the maximum output of a GT 28 RS on RS2
                Surge problem?
                RS2 chip by mihnea,PKM short IM, forge dump valve, 3" custom stainless exhaust, 18"X8" Porsche 996 rims, conti contact 245/35 Front 225/40 Rear, QR sport top mount, Powerflex bushes, aloy sub frame bushes, neuspeed 19mm RARB,Hard tranny mount, V8 torsen on RS2

                Comment

                • Erikb
                  S2Forum Maniac
                  • Jul 2004
                  • 648
                  • Country: Netherlands

                  #23
                  I dont exactly know, maybe the rs2 EM, rs IC and exhaust will be a bottleneck.

                  I bought a 600 x 300 x 76 intercooler and will go for a turbular IM, for exhaust I go for a 3" with a separate wastgate pipe.
                  Last edited by Erikb; 23 September 2005, 19:32.
                  Getting everything sorted out for my 5++ hp project

                  Comment

                  • kalsket
                    S2Forum Fanatic
                    • Sep 2004
                    • 78
                    • Country: Finland

                    #24
                    With GT28RS I would expect 350-400 Hp depending on other hardware. Because it has smaller compressor I think it wouldn't have surge problem or at least it would be smaller.

                    Choosing from 2540/2871 I would take 2871 because 2540 is getting of production if it already hasn't. About their difference I can't say anything more than you can read yourself on atpturbos website.
                    4F 2006 avant 3.0tdi quattro
                    4B 2002 S6 avant quattro
                    typ85 sedan quattro with "minor" changes

                    Comment

                    • maRS2
                      S2Forum Addict
                      • Oct 2003
                      • 366
                      • Home: France Current: Thailand

                      #25
                      Kalsket do you think it's possible to have with a GT28RS
                      2 bar at 2500 rpm and around 380 Hp
                      on a RS2 with full 3" stainless exhaust ( very straight)

                      When do you get full boost on your GT2871 setup
                      RS2 chip by mihnea,PKM short IM, forge dump valve, 3" custom stainless exhaust, 18"X8" Porsche 996 rims, conti contact 245/35 Front 225/40 Rear, QR sport top mount, Powerflex bushes, aloy sub frame bushes, neuspeed 19mm RARB,Hard tranny mount, V8 torsen on RS2

                      Comment

                      • kalsket
                        S2Forum Fanatic
                        • Sep 2004
                        • 78
                        • Country: Finland

                        #26
                        at the moment I get full boost around 2800

                        (I guess GT28RS might do those figures just fine, rpm for full boost might be bit higher than that.)

                        Edit: Checked the compressor map for GT28RS. It will give you max 2 bar and only around 4000 rpm, and with bad efficiency. Here are figures I calculated for that turbo with very well flowing head.

                        rpm / bar / Hp / Nm
                        7500 0,9 365 342
                        7000 1,1 374 375
                        6500 1,1 371 400
                        6000 1,3 372 436
                        5500 1,5 373 476
                        5000 1,55 353 495
                        4500 1,55 324 505
                        4000 1,55 288 505
                        3500 1,2 219 440
                        3000 1,2 188 440
                        2500 1 132 371
                        2000 0,3 67 237
                        Last edited by kalsket; 8 October 2005, 23:34.
                        4F 2006 avant 3.0tdi quattro
                        4B 2002 S6 avant quattro
                        typ85 sedan quattro with "minor" changes

                        Comment

                        • maRS2
                          S2Forum Addict
                          • Oct 2003
                          • 366
                          • Home: France Current: Thailand

                          #27
                          Looking your number I think my RS2 Turbon is better
                          I have 2,1 bar at 3000 rpm
                          RS2 chip by mihnea,PKM short IM, forge dump valve, 3" custom stainless exhaust, 18"X8" Porsche 996 rims, conti contact 245/35 Front 225/40 Rear, QR sport top mount, Powerflex bushes, aloy sub frame bushes, neuspeed 19mm RARB,Hard tranny mount, V8 torsen on RS2

                          Comment

                          • kalsket
                            S2Forum Fanatic
                            • Sep 2004
                            • 78
                            • Country: Finland

                            #28
                            You could be right. At least it is better for the fact that you already have it

                            Just one hint for the future. Boost pressure means just about nothing when comparing two turbos of different size. Air mass is the only thing that counts when you want power. In other words: you can get the same air mass what you get with original turbo with 2,1bar with another turbo with 1,0 or 1,5bar. Therefore in this case look only at the Hp and Nm figures. (RS2 turbo can still be better.)

                            Edit: AFAIK: Anything that RS2 orig. turbo gives above 1,8bar is made with quite bad efficiency = More heat, less air mass.
                            Last edited by kalsket; 10 October 2005, 08:29.
                            4F 2006 avant 3.0tdi quattro
                            4B 2002 S6 avant quattro
                            typ85 sedan quattro with "minor" changes

                            Comment

                            • Jamo
                              Retired OG Mod
                              • Mar 2004
                              • 21750
                              • Country: United Kingdom

                              #29
                              *bump* maRS2 what turbo did you go for in the end?

                              Comment

                              • S4turbo
                                S2Forum Fanatic
                                • Nov 2005
                                • 81
                                • Country: Norway

                                #30
                                Kalsket, how did you retime the cams, what hardware do you have? Can they be retimed individually?

                                Originally posted by kalsket
                                Possibly that may be necessary. Repo is referring to my engine which had surging problem when running AAN ex-cam with ADU cam belt-gear and ADU in-cam.

                                Due to surge boost had to kept in 1.4 bar 3-4,5 krpm. After retiming of cams 1.9bar without any problem.

                                Comment

                                Working...