RS2 Brake Upgrade - Help Please

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • minim
    S2Forum Addict
    • Aug 2013
    • 201
    • Country: Norway

    #106
    Originally posted by twoqu
    I didn't like the info from the start! Bit of a ****** trick to sell something safety critical that doesn't fit. As the end user you shouldn't have to modify anything but thats what I was trying to warn about. The brackets must be made to suit the application. The fact they couldn't tell you what discs they were for on the RS2 set the alarm bells ringing.
    Oh well, I guess all you have lost at the moment is a bit of time. Send them back and cross Hansen of your Yuletide list.
    True..

    Will the VRS adapter fit 100%?

    Comment

    • twoqu
      S2Forum Possessed
      • Sep 2003
      • 3103

      #107
      Personally I wouldn't buy any brackets unless the retailer can tell you exactly what discs they suit. So thats the question to ask.

      Comment

      • minim
        S2Forum Addict
        • Aug 2013
        • 201
        • Country: Norway

        #108
        Originally posted by twoqu
        Personally I wouldn't buy any brackets unless the retailer can tell you exactly what discs they suit. So thats the question to ask.
        VRS said it matched the part numbers I sent him so I guess they do then.. Easiest would be to get the measurements and compare them against what I got now and see if it fits. Only bad thing about the VRS adapters is that they cost 3x the amount of the ones I got now. I think I can get it cheaper by making them myself to be honest. With shipping and 25% VAT I need to pay $550 for those adapters.

        If I can modify them to fit tomorrow I'll just do that for now if it's safe to do, if not I think it's time to make something that fits not to mess around with all this random info that's going around on internet. I'm sure a lot of the wrong info around comes from people that don't care about 3-5mm wrong measurements ^^ I've seen this many times before.

        Comment

        • jade
          S2Forum Extremist
          • Jan 2005
          • 1811
          • Home: New Zealand Current: Spain

          #109
          Can you post the measurement of you brackets and I will compare them to the VRS ones
          RS 2 580HP

          Comment

          • twoqu
            S2Forum Possessed
            • Sep 2003
            • 3103

            #110
            It would be useful to compare the dimensions against the other plans on the other thread to see how close they are. Nothing like a real World comparsion. Obviously there is going to be a bit of tolerence here and there but not mm's!
            Not too sure about modifying the brackets if they are alloy, certaintly not the place to under engineer! If they are steel, I wonder if its possible to move the centre by 4mm and then use a top hat bush to get the axial spacing correct. If you modify the calipers then they will not fit any purpose made brackets.
            Think the solution is to source or make brackets that will do the job first time.

            Comment

            • minim
              S2Forum Addict
              • Aug 2013
              • 201
              • Country: Norway

              #111
              Originally posted by jade
              Can you post the measurement of you brackets and I will compare them to the VRS ones
              Ofcourse. I didn't have anything with high accurancy to do the measuring but I used one of these.



              The measurements comes here. I tried to be as accurate as I could when measuring but without proper tools and enough time it's hard. Should not be far off tho. Will control measure them now just to see that I didn't miss anything when I was drawing this. I got the 3d model saved so I can give you other measurements on request (or the file if you want it). The drawing doesn't include all the angles that are arced on them but I just had to draw something quick to get the measurements before I head off to work.







              Originally posted by twoqu
              It would be useful to compare the dimensions against the other plans on the other thread to see how close they are. Nothing like a real World comparsion. Obviously there is going to be a bit of tolerence here and there but not mm's!
              Not too sure about modifying the brackets if they are alloy, certaintly not the place to under engineer! If they are steel, I wonder if its possible to move the centre by 4mm and then use a top hat bush to get the axial spacing correct. If you modify the calipers then they will not fit any purpose made brackets.
              Think the solution is to source or make brackets that will do the job first time.
              It would. I would like to see measurements of the VRS adapters also for a comparison.

              I won't modify them. After more checking today I realized that there is not enough material to modify the full 4mm that I need.

              Comment

              • twoqu
                S2Forum Possessed
                • Sep 2003
                • 3103

                #112
                As I recall the other bracket dims were both 25mm from centre to the mounting faces.
                Thats probably a bit closer than those but still not spot on!

                Comment

                • jade
                  S2Forum Extremist
                  • Jan 2005
                  • 1811
                  • Home: New Zealand Current: Spain

                  #113
                  Originally posted by minim
                  Ofcourse. I didn't have anything with high accurancy to do the measuring but I used one of these.



                  The measurements comes here. I tried to be as accurate as I could when measuring but without proper tools and enough time it's hard. Should not be far off tho. Will control measure them now just to see that I didn't miss anything when I was drawing this. I got the 3d model saved so I can give you other measurements on request (or the file if you want it). The drawing doesn't include all the angles that are arced on them but I just had to draw something quick to get the measurements before I head off to work.









                  It would. I would like to see measurements of the VRS adapters also for a comparison.

                  I won't modify them. After more checking today I realized that there is not enough material to modify the full 4mm that I need.
                  A couple of quick measurements from mine

                  offset is about 26mm and height 22 to 23mm Will measure correctly tomorrow

                  Yours 24mm and 28.1
                  RS 2 580HP

                  Comment

                  • twoqu
                    S2Forum Possessed
                    • Sep 2003
                    • 3103

                    #114
                    Yep thats closer!
                    Although if we deduct the 4.5mm from the 28mm we are looking at perhaps say 23.5mm. As the gap at the top and bottom was the same then that makes the pad a good fit on the friction surface. It's almost like Porsche meant it to be!
                    That just leaves the axial dimension to firm up.

                    Comment

                    • minim
                      S2Forum Addict
                      • Aug 2013
                      • 201
                      • Country: Norway

                      #115
                      Originally posted by jade
                      A couple of quick measurements from mine

                      offset is about 26mm and height 22 to 23mm Will measure correctly tomorrow

                      Yours 24mm and 28.1
                      Sounds like the vrs adapters will be a perfect fit!

                      I calculated that I needed 1,35mm increase up from 24 but I think it could be measuring errors. 2mm up to 26 is prolly correct. The height was a bit much down but will wait until you can measure it more accurate and pray for the measurements to fit better
                      Last edited by minim; 18 November 2013, 07:48.

                      Comment

                      • jade
                        S2Forum Extremist
                        • Jan 2005
                        • 1811
                        • Home: New Zealand Current: Spain

                        #116
                        Originally posted by minim
                        Sounds like the vrs adapters will be a perfect fit!

                        I calculated that I needed 1,35mm increase up from 24 but I think it could be measuring errors. 2mm up to 26 is prolly correct. The height was a bit much down but will wait until you can measure it more accurate and pray for the measurements to fit better
                        26mm and 23mm is what I have measured from the VRS Ones
                        RS 2 580HP

                        Comment

                        • minim
                          S2Forum Addict
                          • Aug 2013
                          • 201
                          • Country: Norway

                          #117
                          Originally posted by jade
                          26mm and 23mm is what I have measured from the VRS Ones
                          Doesn't sound to bad. If my measures are correct then I would have the caliper placed 1mm to low but since it's that way it can be shimmed up to the correct placement if it's infact to low when mounted. Tempting to order it instead of doing the hassle of getting one made...

                          Comment

                          • twoqu
                            S2Forum Possessed
                            • Sep 2003
                            • 3103

                            #118
                            Usually the OE leave a gap at the top of the disc hence the characteristic wear ridge! So the 23mm would leave in theory a 1mm space around the circumference of the disc. Not sure how tight the clearance is within the wheel but moving the caliper down would give more clearance.

                            Comment

                            • minim
                              S2Forum Addict
                              • Aug 2013
                              • 201
                              • Country: Norway

                              #119
                              Originally posted by twoqu
                              Usually the OE leave a gap at the top of the disc hence the characteristic wear ridge! So the 23mm would leave in theory a 1mm space around the circumference of the disc. Not sure how tight the clearance is within the wheel but moving the caliper down would give more clearance.
                              clearance is no problem even at the hight I have it at now. With a 330mm disc this would be no problem but I've been trying to get that RS2 322mm hat/bell for some time now without luck so I guess that's no option.

                              I bet that having it 1mm lower than the brake disc would give me less break force than having it 4mm above But at least the whole disc is covered. That one millimeter could also be me messing up the measurements a bit as it's hard to measure how far above it is due to access inside the caliper where the pads are showing.

                              Comment

                              • twoqu
                                S2Forum Possessed
                                • Sep 2003
                                • 3103

                                #120
                                I guess its the differences between optimal and acceptable, with the OE standard being the acceptable! Of the two evils the lesser is to have the pads within the disc!
                                Shame those two piece 330X34mm discs are not more readily available but you would still need to find the two piece RS2 discs to rob for the bells/hats. They are nearly as hard to get! Starts to get expensive for the marginal theoretical increase.
                                I'm afraid that you will have to settle for a modest but more cost effective solution. Its still a worthwhile increase in braking performance and for prevention of future maintenance issues.

                                Comment

                                Working...