Disappointing Dyno Result

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • EspenW
    S2Forum Extremist
    • Apr 2007
    • 1534
    • Country: Norway

    #16
    Originally posted by jonnaz
    Tuppu yes i have check the engine timing with a strobe using the ignition lock function in vems.



    Espen thanks. what turbo are you running?
    Old school Turbonetics T04E50 with KKK #8 hotside.
    Running on E85 and that helps spool.

    Do you have any VagCom logs for your car?
    1995 RS2 on Alcohol (6.8sec 100-200km/h)
    1994 80E Avant
    1986 2L Golf 2 on Alcohol

    Comment

    • Jamo
      Retired OG Mod
      • Mar 2004
      • 21750
      • Country: United Kingdom

      #17
      vag-com on vems?

      Comment

      • EspenW
        S2Forum Extremist
        • Apr 2007
        • 1534
        • Country: Norway

        #18
        Originally posted by Jamo
        vag-com on vems?
        Good point...

        Vems log from a 3rd or 4th gear pull on a flat road would be great, though
        1995 RS2 on Alcohol (6.8sec 100-200km/h)
        1994 80E Avant
        1986 2L Golf 2 on Alcohol

        Comment

        • jonnaz
          S2Forum Enthusiast
          • Aug 2009
          • 158
          • Country: United Kingdom

          #19
          Originally posted by EspenW
          Good point...

          Vems log from a 3rd or 4th gear pull on a flat road would be great, though
          Second post in the thread i attached the vems log for the dyno pull shown on the graphs.

          Comment

          • EspenW
            S2Forum Extremist
            • Apr 2007
            • 1534
            • Country: Norway

            #20
            Originally posted by jonnaz
            Second post in the thread i attached the vems log for the dyno pull shown on the graphs.
            Yep, saw that, but 3rd and/or 4th gear WOT logs on a flat road (safe conditions, of course) would be great to see.
            1995 RS2 on Alcohol (6.8sec 100-200km/h)
            1994 80E Avant
            1986 2L Golf 2 on Alcohol

            Comment

            • jonnaz
              S2Forum Enthusiast
              • Aug 2009
              • 158
              • Country: United Kingdom

              #21
              i have found why the spark angle on the log is different to that of the ignition table. the Coolant temp vs MAP ign adjust was adding 8 deg of timing. but the MAT ign retard wqs taking 1 deg out. school boy error. This means I will have to add 7 deg to the ign table. I have changed my ignition table. old and new are shown. old is on the right hand side. compared to other ignition maps how do they look?

              Cheers
              Attached Files

              Comment

              • A80Avant
                S2Forum Obsessed
                • Sep 2005
                • 10873
                • Country: Greece

                #22
                It looks OK to me just use headphones to listen for knock. I agree 480 on this turbo would be absolutely fine and with a few tweaks a bit better. It strikes me though that torque is coming in late. Do u use 7A cams?

                In addition, looking at the log it doesnt make sense why you have a spark angle of 17 when your map asks for 9?

                i may be looking at an older version of vemstune but i dont remember ever having a coolant temp vs ignition timing to ADD timing to a map. There is the MAT vs ignition retart table which is manifold temperature... but the tables there make sense but the addition of the timing in my mind doesnt.

                maybe its late...
                Last edited by A80Avant; 1 July 2014, 21:26.

                Comment

                • jonnaz
                  S2Forum Enthusiast
                  • Aug 2009
                  • 158
                  • Country: United Kingdom

                  #23
                  Originally posted by A80Avant
                  It looks OK to me just use headphones to listen for knock. I agree 480 on this turbo would be absolutely fine and with a few tweaks a bit better. It strikes me though that torque is coming in late. Do u use 7A cams?

                  In addition, looking at the log it doesnt make sense why you have a spark angle of 17 when your map asks for 9?

                  i may be looking at an older version of vemstune but i dont remember ever having a coolant temp vs ignition timing to ADD timing to a map. There is the MAT vs ignition retart table which is manifold temperature... but the tables there make sense but the addition of the timing in my mind doesnt.

                  maybe its late...

                  Hi vas.

                  I have only seen this on the newest version of vems tune. Im running 1.2.23 firmware. I assume this coolant ignition map table is to retard timing for overheating or speed up warm up time on cold start. I don't know. I was told to set the table to 0. Which i did but i must have loaded a config that i had before i set it to 0. It was adding 8 deg when the coolant temp was above 60. And retarding 12 deg below coolant temp of 60. Anyway i will set it to 0 and update the ignition map as shown above.

                  I am running standard 3b cams. When would you expect to see peak torque?

                  Comment

                  • A80Avant
                    S2Forum Obsessed
                    • Sep 2005
                    • 10873
                    • Country: Greece

                    #24
                    HX35 is meant to be able to have full boost on 3d gear by 4000 rpm or sooner. If your runs were done with 4th or above and you have 2.2bar after 4000 rpm I'd say either the turbo is not as previously said to be or your boost settings could need a tweak or you could have a boos leak somewhere and that can also explain partially the over fuelling if it's not VE table related

                    Comment

                    • prj
                      S2Forum Zealot
                      • Mar 2010
                      • 6308
                      • Country: Estonia

                      #25
                      HX35 is just an umbrella designation for many different turbos. It can spool at 3.8k or spool at 4.5k, same as there are many different sized K27 hybrids.
                      http://tuner.ee - http://www.facebook.com/tuner.ee

                      Comment

                      • Thuppu
                        S2Forum Freak
                        • Sep 2010
                        • 4115
                        • Country: Finland

                        #26
                        Here in Finland all HX35's have specific names like 35W, 35W Pro, 35W hybrid, 35 II, 35 FullRace, 35 Pro, 35 Super, 35/40 etc. But I'll guess in other parts of the world it isn't so simpple. Like the yankees when they mix up horse power, ponies and wheel horse power.

                        Audi UrS4 Avant 2.5 20vt - twincharged - Project
                        Audi 80q B4 Sedan 2.2 20vt - Daily user
                        BMW 320d Touring e91 M-Sport - Daily user
                        BMW 740iA e38 - Project

                        Comment

                        • jonnaz
                          S2Forum Enthusiast
                          • Aug 2009
                          • 158
                          • Country: United Kingdom

                          #27
                          Originally posted by EspenW
                          Good point...

                          Vems log from a 3rd or 4th gear pull on a flat road would be great, though
                          EspenW

                          Attached is a log of a 3rd gear pull up the road. i have the boost tapering to 1.9 bar @ 7 K rpm in this log. i will probably taper to 2 bar in he future from 6.5K as peak power is reached at 6K before the engine starts to choke.
                          Attached Files

                          Comment

                          • EspenW
                            S2Forum Extremist
                            • Apr 2007
                            • 1534
                            • Country: Norway

                            #28
                            Originally posted by jonnaz
                            EspenW

                            Attached is a log of a 3rd gear pull up the road. i have the boost tapering to 1.9 bar @ 7 K rpm in this log. i will probably taper to 2 bar in he future from 6.5K as peak power is reached at 6K before the engine starts to choke.
                            Goodie,

                            A few things:

                            Can you copy the time vs. rpm data into an Excel file?

                            Road was flat?
                            Do you know the approximate weight of the car (including driver (and passneger, if any))?
                            Tyre size?
                            1995 RS2 on Alcohol (6.8sec 100-200km/h)
                            1994 80E Avant
                            1986 2L Golf 2 on Alcohol

                            Comment

                            • jonnaz
                              S2Forum Enthusiast
                              • Aug 2009
                              • 158
                              • Country: United Kingdom

                              #29
                              Originally posted by EspenW
                              Goodie,

                              A few things:

                              Can you copy the time vs. rpm data into an Excel file?

                              Road was flat?
                              Do you know the approximate weight of the car (including driver (and passneger, if any))?
                              Tyre size?
                              EspenW

                              attached is the excel file for the log. are you using a virtual dyno for this?

                              weight ect is stated in the excel file.

                              I have VDR but cant get it to work. when I paste the data t the graph goes blank.

                              anyway the road I guess was very slightly uphill. you would say it was flat unless you took allot of notice.

                              I will get some more on a very flat road with more boost at the top end.

                              Thanks
                              Attached Files

                              Comment

                              • EspenW
                                S2Forum Extremist
                                • Apr 2007
                                • 1534
                                • Country: Norway

                                #30
                                Sorry, forgot all about this....

                                Here is your Virtual Dyno power and torque graph with power measured at the wheels.
                                NB: I ssume that you have the standard ARV 5 speed gearbox with 4.11 final drive and 1.22 3rd gear ratio?
                                (that is, by the way, essentially the same ratio as the B5 S4s, so your FATS time of 3.44s (4200-6500rpm in r3d) is very comparable with those. The S2 is quite a bit lighter, though.



                                The VEMS data was in a funky format that didn't show in the Excel file, I had a suspicion, so I copied it into Word and saw that it was nonstandard. Copied back to Excel and got it into standard format.

                                I had to run a heavy smoothing factor (12) in order to get a smooth curve, since the graphs were ocillating wildly at low smoothing, something that is weird with the fantastic 20hz resolution of the VEMS log (vagcom is 2-3hz in comparison)

                                Your 3rd gear, at 1.22 ratio is approx 8% longer than the 6 speeds in the ABY S2 and RS2 (1.323rd) in addition, the 235/40-18 is slightly bigger than the common 225/45-17, so your 3rd gear total gearing is approx 9% longer than for example mine. My test weight including driver is normally 1600-1620kg including driver, though.

                                With the longer ARV 3rd tested on the road it is pretty representable vs a typical ABY/ADU 4th gear pull on a dyno adjusted to a road like sweep rate.

                                For easy comparison, here is your Dyno Dynamics dyno graph with estimated crank numbers:
                                Last edited by EspenW; 21 November 2014, 23:05.
                                1995 RS2 on Alcohol (6.8sec 100-200km/h)
                                1994 80E Avant
                                1986 2L Golf 2 on Alcohol

                                Comment

                                Working...